Which car rental company is considered to be the best in Indianapolis?

Taking our users’ ratings and reviews into consideration, Alamo (8.5 rating), Enterprise Rent-A-Car (8.0 rating) and Dollar (7.4 rating) seem to be the best rental car companies in Indianapolis.

What are gas prices like in Indianapolis?

The average gas price in Indianapolis is ₱58.34/gallon over the past month, costing you anywhere between ₱2,625 and ₱3,792 to fill up a car’s gas tank.

How far in advance should I rent a car in Indianapolis for the best price?

Booking your car rental early can save you up to 36% on your rental. Aim to book your car rental at least 7 days in advance to take advantage of a below average price in Indianapolis.

Can I rent a car for a month in Indianapolis?

Yes, you can rent a car for a month in Indianapolis. Check Cheapflights for the latest prices and car type availability.

What car do most people rent in Indianapolis?

The most popular car chosen by those travelling to Indianapolis is Compact (Ford Focus) based on our Cheapflights data.

Cheap Car Rentals in Indianapolis

What is the cheapest time to rent a car in Indianapolis?

January

₱2,402

February

₱2,859

March

₱3,488

April

₱3,317

May

₱3,488

June

₱3,774

July

₱3,717

August

₱3,545

September

₱3,259

October

₱3,431

November

₱3,031

December

₱2,687

Currently, the cheapest month to rent a car in Indianapolis is January. The most expensive time to rent a car is June. The cheapest prices for each month are shown above, but prices will vary based on availability, how far out you book your rental car, and of course, car type.

Compare available car types for rental in Indianapolis

Top rental agencies in Indianapolis

Browse through some of the top rental car agencies in Indianapolis, including Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Payless and Alamo in Indianapolis. Skim reviews, rental company locations, prices, and more before making your decision.

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

8.2

Very good

130 reviews•18 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

4.0

Mediocre|Mar 2023

Car was not full. Had to get gas on my way out.

3.2

Poor|Jul 2020

The vehicle was reliable and unlimited mileage was needed.

When I arrived they had given all the cars away to walkins. There wasn't any cars available and I had to wait untill a vehicle came in. It wasnt cleaned and the gas tank was empty. It also made me late for my destination by an hour and a half. I had made the reservations 4 or 5 days ahead so I would have a car. Then they gave me a minivan because that's all that they had that came in.

1 out of 44

Enterprise Rent-A-Car Locations in Indianapolis

Payless

6.2

Okay

217 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

I liked nothing, could not even pick up the rental because of a credit card and ID “mismatch”. Ridiculous policy.

10.0

Wonderful|Jul 2023

Never think Payless is less. The pick up and drop off in IND was the same as every other brand. The top brands even share their location and staff with Paylees. Good rental, Good Car, Good Service....

2.0

Poor|Dec 2021

The price was twice what I thought it was when booked trough carrentals.com and the Truck was dirty, including pizza crust from the last customer, also the sticker on the License plate said 6-21 which appeared to be 6 months out of date. Other than that it was great.

10.0

Wonderful|Dec 2021

Quick and easy. Let me change the name on the reservation last minute. Quick and fast pick up and drop off. Overall positive experience.

4.0

Mediocre|Jul 2019

The customer service reps for the pick-up and return locations were very kind and helpful.

Payless allowed me to reserve a car but didn't tell me that their shuttle wasn't working. I waited for 30 minutes before attempting to get a new car rental with Avis and noticed the sign regarding Payless customers speaking with Avis reps for car rental info. Then they didn't have the car I wanted and I had to drive a Jeep Wrangler in a storm. I will not rent from Payless again.

1 out of 73

Alamo

8.5

Very good

89 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Dollar

7.5

Good

56 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Thrifty

7.3

Good

64 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Budget

6.5

Okay

99 reviews•9 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

I did not stand in line for well over an hour as I have done in the past. I went to another vender. The Budget people are not able to run a rental agency in airports.

10.0

Wonderful|Jun 2023

I've had an amazing experience with the vehicle, but I was mislead about the total cost of the vehicle. My confirmation says under $300 for the first week, then when I picked up the vehicle the contract cost was over $400. More the I budgeted for.

10.0

Wonderful|Apr 2023

Counter personnel was the best!

4.0

Mediocre|Mar 2023

Car was good quality, and clean. Pickup was exceedingly long, and it was not made clear that using a credit card for deposit was an option

1 out of 33

Avis

6.3

Okay

33 reviews•7 locations

Check prices

Overview

Hertz

6.3

Okay

97 reviews•2 locations

Check prices

Overview

Car rental FAQs

Which car rental company is considered to be the best in Indianapolis?
Taking our users’ ratings and reviews into consideration, Alamo (8.5 rating), Enterprise Rent-A-Car (8.0 rating) and Dollar (7.4 rating) seem to be the best rental car companies in Indianapolis.
What are gas prices like in Indianapolis?
The average gas price in Indianapolis is ₱58.34/gallon over the past month, costing you anywhere between ₱2,625 and ₱3,792 to fill up a car’s gas tank.
How far in advance should I rent a car in Indianapolis for the best price?
Booking your car rental early can save you up to 36% on your rental. Aim to book your car rental at least 7 days in advance to take advantage of a below average price in Indianapolis.
Can I rent a car for a month in Indianapolis?
Yes, you can rent a car for a month in Indianapolis. Check Cheapflights for the latest prices and car type availability.
What car do most people rent in Indianapolis?
The most popular car chosen by those travelling to Indianapolis is Compact (Ford Focus) based on our Cheapflights data.